Sherman send an order to Hascall on the 19th
of July saying, "Cox is ordered to move on the Atlanta Road
at once…Move your command directly in the rear of General Cox’s
column, keeping in close support of him in advance of his
wagons." We don’t know if the 91st participated
in bending rails that day – they most likely helped make sure
the town was secured as they moved through toward Atlanta.
According to bronze roadside Georgia Historical Markers, Hascall’s
2nd Division made a "right turn" on North
Decatur Road to head directly toward Atlanta. Sherman’s orders
on the 19th for Schofield make it clear that he travel
"by the road leading from Doctor Powell’s to Atlanta."
That can only be interpreted as the North Decatur Road. The nature
of the woods and hills of the area demand most of the troops
travel on a roadway. Another field order of the day says all
ammunition wagons and ambulances (wagons) will be left behind to
the north of Decatur until the result is determined. From
Schofield’s biography, states that his Corps was striking south
and west on the 19th with Hascall’s Division (and the
91st) in the advance. Some two miles out of town he
encountered a heavy force of Confederate cavalry who could do
little to hinder the division’s progress. And that by mid
afternoon Hascall’s division was tramping into Decatur. A
disability report on Pvt. William Williams states he was wounded
on the 19th. However there was no mention in his diary
of 91st wounded on that day and fighting was sparse. He
did mention seeing wounded the next day. Also, Confederate cavalry
generally used breach-loading carbines that did not shoot Minie
ball bullets of the type that wounded Pvt. Williams.
Hascall’s division camped that night closer to Atlanta, at
the juncture of Pea Vine Creek and Clifton Road (per bronze
markers on the road), about 5 miles from Atlanta as the crow
flies. Clifton Road today is a rather long road that goes through
the Emory University campus and the Centers for Disease Control
before going south through the present Druid Hills and then
straight line south all the way to what is Flat Shoals Parkway due
east of the center of Atlanta. HE also wrote that he was a mile
and a half from Cheatham’s entrenchments with a high ridge and a
hollow between. It is likely that the 91st had caught
up with their main body of their division by then. Gen. Cox wrote
that on the night of the 19th Schofield was over the
south fork of Peachtree, and at the Peyton plantations. And also
that the Pea Vine is parallel to Cheatham’s entrenchments. The
91st Indiana encampment there is just a few hundred
yards south of North Decatur Road on Pea Vine Creek and near the
southern boundary of Emory University’s campus. This is a very
lovely, peaceful, hilly, wooded area. Pea Vine Creek leaves this
area and goes north along the western boundary of the campus. This
is an area called Druid Hills. There are many vistas of the tall
skyscrapers of Atlanta. The present Druid Hills Golf Course is
less than a half mile south of it. The homes are on large acreage.
To the southeast about a mile is the Fernbank Museum of Natural
History. On July 19, 1864, just one mile to the west of their
encampment, is entrenched the middle of Gen. Cheatham’s line of
Hood’s old Corps. A message is sent to Washington DC that the
left of the force "swung around destroying the Augusta
Railroad from near Stone Mountain to Decatur." One more
indication that there was operations further east where Pvt.
Holder indicates the 91st has gone "8 miles
south-east" on the 18th. We now see he may have shown us they
went nearly all the way to Stone Mountain on the 18th
to intercept the railroad track and tear it up over a 3 to 5 mile
stretch leading back to Decatur. Then heading west, covering the
distance back to Decatur, and on even further west to camp. So the
detailed data doesn’t conflict with Holder but rather confirms
his observations. The summary of 91st battles
indicates, "On the 19th the 91st was
engaged at Decatur…the whole line skirmishing heavily."
Then finally, just before midnight, Sherman tells Cox, "a
general movement of the army on Atlanta is ordered at 5 AM
tomorrow (20th)".
Dawn of Wednesday the 20th of July 1864, the day
that Pvt. William Williams’s life changed unalterably, the
outlook was for a fiercely hot Atlanta day. Four hours earlier
Sherman has telegraphed Thomas saying the Augusta railroad line is
torn up and a locomotive has blown up and encumbered the track on
the Macon line. He says, "now is the time to strike in force….
We only must determine where are the artificial defenses of the
enemy." Castell says neither of the armies can see each other
at this point and that the battlefield is essentially covered in
pine forests and dense underbrush. The Battle of Peachtree Creek
is about to begin. A Georgia Historical Marker in bronze stands in
2001 at Briarcliff Road and University Drive which silently speaks
of the surrounding events of July 20th, "…a wide
gap (developed) between Peachtree Rd. (the left of Thomas’
forces) and Schofield’s 23rd Army Corps, posted at
the intersection of North Decatur and Briarcliff roads. To fill
this gap Stanley’s and Woods 4th Army Corps divisions
were moved southeast from Buckhead. Stanley’s in the valley west
of this marker (currently the Georgia Mental Health Institute) and
Schofield’s 23rd Army Corps prolonged Stanley’s
line southward. All seems in readiness for what everyone knows
will come-- a rebel charge. Gen. Hood hears at 10 AM that Sherman’s
left wing including McPherson’s Corps and some of Schofield’s
23rd Corps is marching slowly and with large numbers
from Decatur to Atlanta. The speed is only one mile every three
hours. Logan’s Corps, followed by Dodge’s going west on the
Decatur Road. Schofield’s (with the 91st Indiana) on
the North Decatur Road. A telegraph of July 20 9:30 AM states,
"The Twenty-third Corps is moving on the Atlanta road, about
a mile and a half to the right of the road the Fifteenth Corps is
now on (main road parallel with and along the railroad). Our
advance is not quite four miles from Atlanta and has developed the
enemy’s works in our front." Major JA Campbell signed it.
McPherson moving west on the parallel road to the south. They
are moving essentially unopposed. Cheatham slides to his right one
mile south to protect the Decatur Road as well as the North
Decatur Road (on which is the 91st Indiana). Hood still
expects the rebel attack to start at 11 AM. But Cheatham moves
slowly and not one mile but two miles to his right. Hardee sees
the problem but can’t notify Hood who is moving at the time. So
Hardee starts moving his troops the two miles also and when Hood
finds out does nothing. Hardee is one of the best commanders in
the rebel army but he has been incensed at being passed over for
Johnston’s replacement. He takes until nearly 3 PM to make a
one-mile shift and stops. Meanwhile McPherson’s cavalry has
moved to within 2-1/2 miles from Atlanta via the Decatur Road by 1
PM and fired three shells from a 20-pound parrot gun into the
city.
Cheatham’s line doesn’t reach as far down as the Decatur
Road and Wheeler only has 3,500 cavalry versus McPherson’s
25,000 infantry. But McPherson decides to take the time to deploy
troops from above Decatur Road where they join Schofield’s
deployment of Blair with Logan to Blair’s right and Hascall
(with the 91st Indiana at about ½ mile above Decatur
Road) to Logan’s right and Cox to Hascall’s right. As evening
approaches McPherson decides to not advance more. At 4 PM the
rebel attack begins on the far left and is staged to roll to the
right. The main battle is just 2 or 3 miles to the north of North
Decatur Road where Sherman is but he cannot hear it because of the
hills and trees. Anyway, Thomas is taking the brunt of the rebel
attack and is holding. About that time, Sherman orders Thomas to
attack forward to Atlanta sweeping everything before him.
At midnight Sherman gets news from Thomas marked 6:15PM saying
repulsed heavy attack with enemy’s losses severe. Sherman now
sees the main rebel thrust is north and McPherson should have done
better in outflanking from the east. In Schofield’s deployment
Cox is to the right of Hascall (and the 91st) and Logan’s
XV Corps is abreast of Schofield and to his left. Dodge is behind
near Decatur. The summary of regimental action says, "On the
20th, the enemy made a sudden assault, resulting in the
battle of Peachtree Creek, in which the regiment was
engaged." This is somewhat of a confirmation of Holder’s
saying they got within 4 miles of Atlanta. Sherman wires
Washington DC at 9 PM saying in part, "we have pressed the
enemy back to where our rifle-shot can reach the town…Thomas is
on my right, Schofield in the center and McPherson on the left…the
enemy still clings to his entrenchments…our line extends from a
point on the railroad 2-1/2 miles east of Atlanta ...and we have
torn up 5 miles of the track.".
Separately on the 20th, Sherman at 6 PM telegraphs,
"General Schofield is near the distillery (believe
this to be near the intersection of Ponce de Leon and Briarcliff
Ave. based on 1864 maps indicating the distillery) where the enemy
is fortifying…the enemy attempted to sally against Cox but were
quickly repulsed. I saw the skirmishers of the other
division of Schofield’s (very probably Hascall’s) make a dash
at a line of rifle-pits, carrying it and capturing about 100
prisoners….all the prisoners captured by Schofield are Hoods
corps (Cheatham in this battle)….all the ground I’ve
seen is densely wooded but the roads are good." This all is
fascinating. First, the distillery (based on 1864 map) is in front
of Schofield but is about 2 miles from Atlanta. On Schofield’s
left McPherson has gotten within 2-1/2 miles early in the day so
this is credible. But what skirmishers in Hascall’s 2nd
division rushed the rifle-pits and captured 100 prisoners? We turn
to the official report for that day. The official report of the 91st
Indiana Volunteers by Col. Butterfield states, "On the 20th,
as the (First) brigade was advancing on the Atlanta and Decatur
road, Companies A and B were sent out as skirmishers under
command of Captain Clark of Company B, and assisted in driving the
enemy, with a loss of 3 men wounded (one of which
was Pvt. Williams). The companies captured during
the afternoon from 15 to 20 prisoners." Within the 91st
Indiana Volunteer Regiment it is recorded: Henry Abe died a week
later of wounds, Elihu Wilson of Company B died on the 21st
of wounds at Atlanta), and William Carter (Co. C) died a month
later at Marietta.
General Sherman’s memoirs also say of the 20th:
" I was with Gen. Schofield near the center and soon after
noon heard heavy firing in front of Thomas’s right, which lasted
an hour or so and then ceased. I soon learned the enemy made a
furious sally (mostly)…on Hooker’s Corps…the troops crossed
Peachtree Creek and were resting … enemy came pouring out of
their trenches down upon them." The sally was repulsed with
many Confederate losses. Further he stated of that day, "We
then advanced our lines in compact order, close up to the finished
entrenchments…from various parts of our lines we could see the
houses inside of Atlanta, though between us were the strong
parapets with ditches and chevaux de frise, and abatis…".
He stated that Schofield was on the right of McPherson and Dodge
between was "crowded out." Also that he (Sherman)
personally was on horseback at the front of Schofield’s line
which had advanced in front of the Howard House to some open
ground where he could plainly see the whole rebel line of parapets
and saw the men dragging trees and saplings from the intervening
valley, by the distillery, to be used for abatis. He could see the
rebel line strongly manned. Schofield was "dressing
forward his lines at the front. Sherman and McPherson held
their last meeting that day and McPherson soon lay dead from a
rebel bullet.
General Schofield’s biography doesn’t say much of the day.
Mostly that they moved forward a mile or so against stubborn
resistance. Then Hood saw a chance and sent troops pouring into a
gap between Thomas and Schofield about noon. Artillery with
canister shot drove them back. General Thomas telegraphed Gen.
Sherman on midnight of the 20th that, "…the
enemy’s line of battle confronts my troops, with his left at
Turner’s Ferry and his right resting on what I take to be Pea
Vine Creek." Sherman replies, "…General
Schofield is near the distillery, where the enemy is fortifying….Gen.
McPherson is on the railroad about 2-1/2 miles out.." and
further, "All the prisoners captured by Schofield are of Hood’s
corps although each commander says he has to fight two corps. All
the ground is densely wooded but the roads are good."
So that Wednesday, the 20th, was relatively quiet
for the 23rd Corps and for the 91st Indiana
Regiment (except for apparently furious bloody skirmishes at the
front by Companies A and B) compared to Gen. Thomas’ lot. But
there had been skirmishes and fighting. They were engaged.
Cheatham’s corps was directly in front of them. And Private
William Williams of 23rd Corps, 2nd
Division, 91st Indiana Regiment, Company A has been
shot through the arm by a rebel rifle bullet. The
conditions indicate they were able to take care of the wounded.
They had the upper hand over the enemy. So it was likely William
was taken to a field hospital by wagon with the other wounded. Pvt.
Holder writes in his diary for July 20th, "marched
within 4 miles of Atlanta (would be about Briarcliff Road), was on
skirmish line, several men was killed, we was in a close
place, and saw wounded of the 91st." This is
pretty clear even though brief. The meaning of "close
place" possibly means packed into a swail or valley or it
could mean close to the enemy. Probably both are true.
It appears from the records indicated in bold above that, on
the 20th of July, Companies A and B of the 91st
Indiana Volunteer Regiment, with Pvt. Williams and Pvt. Holder,
are part of a group sent out as skirmishers to engage Gen.
Cheatham’s Confederate works near the distillery. Sherman saw
them "make a dash at a line of rifle-pits, carrying
it and capturing about 100 prisoners." We know that Companies
A and B of the 91st Indiana accounted for 15-20
Confederate prisoners of Cheatham’s (formerly Hood’s)
Corps. This is the critical day of the critical battle of the
critical city of the critical war to save the Union, and Pvt.
William Williams is dashing at the rebel works before Atlanta,
taking the works and taking prisoners. This is the stuff of
which heroes are made and the stuff of which legends are made. But
he can’t enjoy the victory—he is badly wounded.
Pvt. William Williams’s whole world now collapses onto one
thing --his arm. And what will happen to it. Will he lose it? It
is a terrible wound for an arm wound. And would it kill him? The
dangers of infections, gangrene or bleeding to death were very
high. There was probably some kind of collection of the wounded
into an area near the North Decatur Road to wait for the ambulance
wagons in the rear to be brought up for them. The distance from
the holding area and the return trip to the 23rd Corps
Powell House hospital is about 5-6 miles round trip. It is likely
Pvt. Williams was treated with tourniquets to retard bleeding and
maybe pain in the field but he didn’t get to the hospital until
the main action was over and the transportation on the congested
roadway would allow it—meaning sometime that evening. Wounded
only got some sympathy and kindness for hours or days. Medical
help was so archaic. Partly because of the ignorance of the day.
Germs and bacteria were unknown. Pus was considered a blessing.
Surgeon’s instruments were not even rinsed in most cases. Many
limbs were likely removed there that night as Pvt. Williams tried
to rest and calm his nerves. And Pvt. Williams could probably hear
the terrible sounds involved. But at least he was safe from enemy
fire. What happened to him now depended on his own body’s
resources. He could readily die from infections and from catching
diseases from sick men in the hospital. They did no isolation and
no sterilization. Not invented yet.
Somewhere we have read he was taken later to a major Union
hospital in Knoxville. He spent a long time convalescing in a
hospital in Evansville and was discharged on the 15th
of March 1865 at Evansville by Col. Simonson. He listed that his
address is Evansville. An Army Map commissioned by Gen. Sherman in
1865 shows there was a military hospital on the west end of the
Evansville area about 1/3rd the way from city center to
W. Franklin (William’s home). This put the hospital about 7
miles from home. One casualty sheet says he suffered from a
"ball flesh wound to the left arm". Another states the
wound entry was at the rear of the arm about midway between elbow
and wrist. Another says he was "incapable of duties because
of contraction of extensor muscles of the left hand and all
fingers press on the palm….gunshot fracture of the ulna received
in battle near Atlanta Georgia about 19 July 1864….he is unfit
for duty due to the degree of his disability- one hand."
There are many questions that will remain unanswered. Did the
shooter take aim at him and fire? Or was it a stray bullet? We
will never know. But it is likely that it was and infantryman of
Gen. Cheatham’s Corps that he took over from Gen. Hood, who
replaced Johnston just one day before Pvt. Williams was shot. Many
soldiers had to plead with the surgeons to not amputate their
limbs. Gen. Sherman writes of a col. Reynolds shot in the leg near
where Pvt. Williams was shot. He was of Irish birth and stated
that the leg was very valuable being "imported". The
surgeons got a laugh and figured he had the spunk to survive the
wound. He retained his leg. William Williams’s story was never
recorded. Likely there were no jokes told. But he certainly
pleaded a case based on being a farmer. At that point he had no
way of knowing his hand would clam up as it did. His arm was
likely still useful to some degree but not well enough to hold a
gun.
The War of the Rebellion’s toll in humanity was crushing to
the country. Approximately 359,000 Federal soldiers and 258,000
Confederate soldiers lost their lives. More by the illnesses than
wounds but the effect is the same. And the toll on the physically
and mentally disabled adds to that. William Williams was not
killed in the war but he lived for only five years after the war.
Friends said he was never the same and his early death was felt to
be because of the war.
| Next page |